Most of us learned to build a campfire for warmth and for the pleasure of watching it. A cooking fire is a different animal. Tall flames look great in the evening but they scorch the outside of food, leave the inside raw and coat every pan in soot. What we actually want for cooking is a deep, even bed of glowing coals, and getting there takes a bit of planning and about forty-five minutes of patience. Here is how we do it on a typical car camping trip, from the moment we arrive at the site to the moment the last cobbler comes off the fire.
Start with the fire ring, not the wood
Before anything else, look at the ring or pit you have been given. Clear out the half-burned logs, foil scraps and bottle caps that previous campers left behind, because old rubbish smokes and smells and can flare up unpredictably. If there is a metal grate, check that it swings freely and sits level; a grate that tilts will slide your pan into the ash. If there is no grate, rake the ash flat and set two flat rocks or a couple of green logs on either side to hold a grill or a pot. Keep a bucket of water within arm’s reach, and know where the nearest tap is. This is not just about safety, it is also the fastest way to cool a fire that has become too hot to cook on.
Take a moment to notice the wind. A steady breeze feeds a fire more oxygen than you might expect, so on windy evenings we build smaller and lower, and we cook on the sheltered side of the ring.
Choose wood for coals, not for flames
The single biggest difference between a warming fire and a cooking fire is the wood. Softwoods such as pine, spruce and fir catch quickly and burn bright, which makes them ideal for kindling, but they burn out fast and leave very little in the way of coals. Hardwoods such as oak, maple, beech, ash and birch burn slower, hotter and collapse into dense coals that hold their heat for an hour or more. If you can only get one bundle, get hardwood and use a few thin splits of it as kindling.
Wood should be dry and seasoned, meaning it has been cut and stored for at least six months. Seasoned wood is lighter than it looks, has cracks radiating from the centre of each round, and makes a hollow knock when two pieces are tapped together. Green wood hisses, smokes and refuses to make coals. Wherever you camp, buy or gather firewood locally rather than bringing it from home; moving wood between regions is one of the main ways tree-killing insects spread, and many parks now forbid it outright.
Build a structure that collapses into a bed
We use a small teepee of kindling for ignition and then switch to a log cabin around it. The teepee catches fast; the cabin, built from splits roughly the thickness of your wrist, burns evenly from all sides and falls inward as it goes, which is exactly what produces a flat bed rather than a heap. Light it from the upwind side so the flames are pushed into the structure, and resist the urge to add wood too early. A fire that has plenty of air moving through it will roar into life on its own.
Once the cabin is fully alight, keep feeding it with hardwood splits for another twenty to thirty minutes. This is the part beginners skip, and it is the reason so many campfire meals turn out badly. You are not making a fire yet; you are making fuel. Only when the flames have died right down and you have a pile of coals 10 to 15 cm (4 to 6 in) deep, glowing orange under a thin skin of white ash, are you ready to cook.
Learn the hand test
Cooking on coals is about matching heat to the food. Hold your palm about 12 cm (5 in) above the coals and count how many seconds you can keep it there comfortably:
- 1 to 2 seconds: very hot, good for searing steaks, blistering peppers and boiling water quickly.
- 3 to 4 seconds: medium-hot, ideal for burgers, sausages, chicken pieces and foil packets.
- 5 to 6 seconds: medium, the sweet spot for most Dutch oven cooking, fish and vegetables.
- 7 seconds or more: low, for simmering, keeping things warm and finishing baked goods.
The test is not scientific but it is remarkably consistent once you have used it a few times, and it is far more useful than trying to guess from the colour of the coals alone.
Manage zones, and keep a feeder fire going
The trick that changes everything is to stop thinking of the fire as one temperature. Use a long-handled shovel or a stout stick to rake the coals into zones: a thick layer on one side for high heat, a thinner layer in the middle for medium, and bare ground or a sparse scattering on the far side where food can rest without cooking further. When a burger flares up, slide it to the cool zone instead of pulling it off entirely. When the potatoes need a boost, push a shovelful of fresh coals underneath them.
Because coals lose heat steadily, we always keep a small feeder fire burning at the back of the ring, well away from the pans. Every fifteen minutes or so we shovel new coals from the feeder to the cooking zone and push the spent, grey ones to the edge. This is what allows a long meal, say a Dutch oven chili followed by a cobbler, to be cooked without ever waiting for a fresh fire. Ash is the enemy of heat, so tap the top of the bed occasionally with the shovel to knock the white layer off and expose the orange beneath.
Cook with the fire, then put it out properly
Hold pans on a grate rather than directly in the coals whenever you can; the air gap gives you more control and keeps the bottoms of the pans from becoming coated with hardened tar. For Dutch ovens, set the pot on a shallow layer of coals and pile more on the lid; for foil packets, nestle them at the edge of the medium zone and turn them every few minutes. Keep heavy leather gloves and a pair of long tongs within reach, and never leave the cooking zone unattended once food is on, because coals are quiet, and they are easy to forget.
When dinner is over, let the remaining coals burn down while you wash up, then drown them thoroughly. Pour water slowly, stir the ash with the shovel, and pour again until everything is cold enough to touch with the back of your hand. A fire ring that is still warm in the morning was not put out; it was left. Done right, the whole process takes about five minutes, and it means the next campers, and the forest around them, will still be there when you come back.
